Online ordering is coming soon. For now, email us to place an order.

Made with love

Homemade happiness in every bite.

Sweet homemade cookies for everyday treats and special occasions. Chocolate chip, crumb cake, Italian knots and more, baked fresh to order on Long Island.

VIEW OUR COOKIES ASK ABOUT AN ORDER

Local pickup and delivery · Order 48 hours ahead

Gaga's Cookies mascot: the baker holding a plate of cookies

Celebrating something?

Cookies for any occasion

Birthdays Baby showers Bridal showers Graduations Engagement parties Thank-you gifts Holidays

Planning a party? Send us your date, headcount and theme, and we'll put together a custom order.

ASK ABOUT AN ORDER

Easy as 1, 2, 3

How ordering works

1

Pick your cookies

Choose flavors and box sizes from the menu, or build a Cookie Flight.

2

Choose a time

Pick a pickup or delivery time at least 48 hours out.

3

We bake, you enjoy

Your cookies are baked fresh, boxed, and ready when you are.

Gaga's Cookies avatar illustration of the baker

The baker behind the box

Meet Gaga

Gaga's Cookies started in a home kitchen with family recipes and a lot of butter. Every order is baked fresh after you place it, never sitting on a shelf.

From birthday parties and baby showers to a Tuesday that just needs a cookie, we bake for every occasion. Thank you for supporting a small, local, homemade business.

Good to know

Questions

How far ahead should I order?

At least 48 hours. For parties or large orders, a week ahead is best.

Do you ship?

No. We offer local pickup and delivery within New York State only.

Where do you deliver?

Local delivery on Long Island. Send us your town and date and we'll confirm.

Can I mix flavors?

Yes. The Cookie Flight lets you pick 4 flavors, 3 of each.

Do you do custom or party orders?

Yes. Send us a message with your date, quantity and theme.

What about allergens?

Our cookies are made in a home kitchen that also handles wheat, eggs, dairy and nuts. We can't guarantee any item is allergen free.